This year they each got a cake of their very own E likes only white cake so that was easy and he wanted Footprints (He really wanted a shoe to step in the cake for a real footprint, but I talked him out of it) and "Mystery Marks" AKA question marks.
Cake was the first thing on the party agenda. My neighbour did that at a party last week and I thought it was an awesome idea for a 2o'clock birthday party! We sang separate Happy Birthday songs and had a separate blowing out of the candles on each.
The best part about 2 cakes - lots of leftovers!