When I saw these mayflower place card holders at 4CrazyKings I knew they would be a perfect craft for us. Luke even got in on the crafting. (and it's a good thing or our masts would be terribly tilted.)
I forgot to pick up coffee stirrers so we used bamboo skewers I had on hand. Oh and I just ran in and asked Starbucks for a stack of sleeves and they were super happy to hand some over. We were also impatient with gluing (but hot glue would have worked nicely) so we used a tape/stapler combo. The nice thing about skewers is they poked right through the masts and no adhesive was needed for that part.
Thanks for sharing your ideas MamaKing!